Human Resource Management I: The Conceptual Framework, Human Resource Planning, Job Analysis, Recruitment, Selection, Placement and Induction
1. The conceptual framework of HRM
Human resource management is the part of management concerned with people at work and their relationships within the organisation. Its history runs through four stages. Welfare work came first: in India the Royal Commission on Labour (1931) recommended labour officers, and the Factories Act 1948 made a welfare officer compulsory in factories employing 500 or more workers, which is how many Indian personnel departments began. Personnel management, from the 1940s, was an administrative and largely reactive function: records, recruitment, discipline, wages and the handling of unions. Human resource management, from the 1980s, treats people as assets to be developed rather than costs to be minimised, and gives the line manager a larger role. Strategic HRM aligns HR policies with business strategy. The Indian Institute of Personnel Management (Calcutta, 1948) and the National Institute of Labour Management (Bombay, 1950) merged in 1980 to form the National Institute of Personnel Management, the profession's main body in India.
| Dimension | Personnel management | Human resource management |
|---|---|---|
| View of employees | A cost; a factor of production | An asset and a source of competitive advantage |
| Nature | Reactive, administrative, rule-bound | Proactive, developmental, strategic |
| Employee relations | Pluralist; collective bargaining with unions | More unitarist; commitment and individual contracts |
| Who does it | A specialist department | Line managers with HR as a partner |
Two models frame the concept. The Michigan or "matching" model (Fombrun, Tichy and Devanna, 1984) is a hard model: HR is a resource to be matched to strategy through a cycle of selection, performance, appraisal, rewards and development. The Harvard model (Beer, Spector and colleagues, 1984) is a soft model: stakeholder interests and situational factors shape HRM policy choices (employee influence, HR flow, reward systems and work systems), which should produce the "four Cs" — commitment, competence, congruence and cost-effectiveness — and long-term consequences for individuals, the organisation and society. David Guest's model (1987) added the goals of strategic integration, high commitment, high quality and flexibility. The functions of HRM are usually grouped as acquisition, development, motivation (compensation and appraisal) and maintenance (welfare, safety and employee relations).
2. Human resource planning
Human resource (manpower) planning is the process of forecasting an organisation's future demand for people, forecasting the supply it can expect, and planning to close the gap: getting the right number of the right people in the right jobs at the right time. The process is: analyse the organisation's objectives and plans; forecast demand; take stock of present manpower (a skills inventory); forecast supply, internal and external; estimate the net requirement (shortage or surplus); and draw up action plans for recruitment, training, promotion, redeployment or, in surplus, a hiring freeze, voluntary retirement or retrenchment. It operates at the national level (manpower planning in the Five-Year Plans), the sectoral level, the industry level and the unit level.
| Forecasting | Techniques |
|---|---|
| Demand | Managerial judgement (bottom-up and top-down); the Delphi technique; work-study and workload analysis; ratio-trend analysis; regression and econometric models |
| Internal supply | Skills inventories; replacement charts; succession planning; Markov analysis of the probabilities of staying, moving and leaving; labour turnover and absenteeism analysis |
| External supply | Labour-market data, graduates from institutions, competitors' demand, demographic and migration trends |
3. Job analysis
Job analysis is the systematic collection of information about a job: its tasks, duties and responsibilities, and the knowledge, skills, abilities and other characteristics a person needs to do it. It yields two documents. The job description states what the job is: title, location, duties, responsibilities, working conditions, tools, and reporting relationships. The job specification states what the job-holder must bring: education, experience, skills, physical and mental abilities, and personal qualities. Job analysis is the foundation of almost every other HR activity: HR planning, recruitment and selection, training needs, performance standards, job evaluation and wage fixation, safety, and job design.
- Methods: observation; interviews with job-holders and supervisors; structured questionnaires; diaries and logs; the critical incident technique (John Flanagan, 1954); technical conferences.
- Structured instruments: the Position Analysis Questionnaire (Ernest McCormick, 194 job elements); Functional Job Analysis (Sidney Fine), rating a job's relation to data, people and things; the Management Position Description Questionnaire.
- Job design follows from analysis: job simplification (Taylor's legacy), job rotation, job enlargement (horizontal loading, more tasks at the same level) and job enrichment (vertical loading, more responsibility and autonomy, from Herzberg).
- Hackman and Oldham's job characteristics model (1976) names five core dimensions: skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy and feedback.
4. Recruitment
Recruitment is the process of searching for prospective employees and stimulating them to apply; Edwin Flippo defined it as "the process of searching for prospective employees and stimulating and encouraging them to apply for jobs in an organisation". It is a positive process that widens the pool, while selection is often called negative because it rejects most applicants. Internal sources are promotion, transfer, re-employment of former employees and employee referrals; they raise morale and cost less but narrow the pool and can breed inbreeding. External sources are advertisement, employment exchanges, campus recruitment, placement agencies and consultants, walk-ins, job portals and social media, and recommendations of unions. In India the Employment Exchanges (Compulsory Notification of Vacancies) Act 1959 requires establishments in the public sector, and private establishments employing 25 or more persons, to notify vacancies to the employment exchange (it does not oblige them to recruit through it); the Act is now consolidated into the Code on Social Security 2020. Badli (substitute) lists are a traditional source in Indian factories, and public employment is subject to reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes, the Economically Weaker Sections and persons with disabilities.
5. Selection, placement and induction
Selection is choosing from the applicants those most likely to succeed in the job. The usual sequence is: preliminary screening of applications; application blank (a weighted application blank scores items that predict success); selection tests; interviews; reference and background checks; the selection decision; physical (medical) examination; and the offer of appointment. Each step is a hurdle, which is why this is called the successive-hurdles approach. Tests are of ability (intelligence, aptitude), achievement or proficiency (trade tests), personality, interest, and situational tests such as the in-basket exercise, the leaderless group discussion and the assessment centre, which combines several exercises observed by trained assessors. A good test must be reliable (it gives consistent results on repetition) and valid (it measures what it claims to measure and predicts job performance); a test can be reliable without being valid, but not valid without being reliable.
Interviews may be structured (patterned, the same questions for every candidate), unstructured (non-directive), stress, panel, behavioural (asking how the candidate actually handled past situations) or situational (asking what he would do). Interviewers make predictable errors: the halo effect, first impressions, contrast effects between successive candidates, similar-to-me bias, and stereotyping; structured interviews and trained panels reduce them. Placement is assigning the selected person to the job for which he or she was selected, and matching the person's abilities to the job's demands; a wrong placement shows up as absenteeism, accidents and turnover. Induction (orientation) is introducing the new employee to the organisation, the job, colleagues, rules, standing orders, welfare facilities, safety rules and grievance procedure; a planned induction programme reduces early turnover, which is highest in the first weeks of employment (the "induction crisis").
Key takeaways
- HRM grew from welfare work (the Factories Act 1948 welfare officer at 500 workers) and personnel management; it treats people as assets, involves line managers and, as strategic HRM, aligns HR with strategy.
- Michigan matching model (hard, 1984) and Harvard model (soft, 1984, the four Cs: commitment, competence, congruence, cost-effectiveness); Guest (1987).
- HR planning forecasts demand (Delphi, workload, ratio-trend) and supply (skills inventory, replacement charts, Markov analysis) and closes the gap; turnover = separations ÷ average workforce × 100.
- Job analysis yields the job description (the job) and the job specification (the person); methods include observation, interview, questionnaire, critical incidents, PAQ and functional job analysis; job design moves from simplification to enlargement and enrichment.
- Recruitment is positive (widening the pool), selection negative (successive hurdles); tests must be reliable and valid; placement matches person to job; induction reduces early turnover. The 1959 Act requires vacancies to be notified, not filled, through employment exchanges.
Practice questions (10)
Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.
The document that states the education, skills and personal qualities a job-holder must have is the
Show answer
Answer: C — job specification
The job specification describes the person the job needs; the job description describes the job itself (duties, responsibilities, conditions). Job evaluation ranks jobs for pay, and enrichment is a job-design technique.The "four Cs" of commitment, competence, congruence and cost-effectiveness belong to
Show answer
Answer: C — the Harvard model of HRM
The Harvard model (Beer and colleagues, 1984) is the soft model in which stakeholder interests and situational factors shape policy choices whose HR outcomes are the four Cs. The Michigan model is the hard matching model of the same year.Which technique forecasts internal manpower supply from the probabilities of employees staying in a job, moving to another or leaving?
Show answer
Answer: B — Markov analysis
Markov analysis uses a transition matrix of historical movement probabilities to project how many people will be in each job next period. Delphi and ratio-trend analysis forecast demand, and functional job analysis is a method of analysing jobs.Assertion (A): Recruitment is described as a positive process and selection as a negative one. Reason (R): Recruitment tries to enlarge the pool of applicants, while selection eliminates the unsuitable at each successive hurdle.
Show answer
Answer: A — Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Both are true and R explains A: the labels describe direction, not value — recruitment stimulates as many suitable people as possible to apply, and selection rejects most of them, step by step, to find the fittest.Assertion (A): A selection test that gives the same ranking of candidates every time it is used must be a valid predictor of job performance. Reason (R): Reliability is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for validity.
Show answer
Answer: D — A is false, but R is true
A is false: consistency (reliability) does not show that the test measures what predicts performance. R is true: a test cannot be valid unless it is reliable, but a reliable test can still measure the wrong thing, as a scale that always reads two kilograms heavy does.Which of these are internal sources of recruitment? Select all that apply.
Show answer
Answer: C — Promotion; D — Transfer
Promotion and transfer fill a vacancy from within the organisation. Campus recruitment and employment exchanges bring in people from outside, so they are external sources.Adding more tasks at the same level of skill and responsibility to a job is called
Show answer
Answer: D — job enlargement
Job enlargement is horizontal loading: more tasks of a similar kind. Job enrichment is vertical loading, adding responsibility, planning and autonomy, as Herzberg urged; rotation moves people between jobs, and simplification narrows a job.Which is NOT one of the five core job dimensions in Hackman and Oldham's job characteristics model?
Show answer
Answer: D — Job security
The five core dimensions are skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy and feedback. Job security is a hygiene factor in Herzberg's scheme and not part of this model.A factory had 36 separations during the year and an average workforce of 900. What is its labour turnover rate by the separation method, in per cent? Type the number.
Numerical answer — type the value.
Show answer
Answer: 4
Turnover = separations ÷ average workforce × 100 = 36 ÷ 900 × 100 = 4 per cent. The flux method would add accessions to separations before dividing, and would give a higher figure.In which year was the Employment Exchanges (Compulsory Notification of Vacancies) Act enacted? Type the year.
Numerical answer — type the value.
Show answer
Answer: 1959
The Act of 1959 requires public-sector establishments, and private establishments employing 25 or more persons, to notify vacancies to employment exchanges; it does not compel them to recruit the candidates the exchange sends.