Human Geography — Nature and Scope
Naturalisation of Humans and Humanisation of Nature
How much does nature decide, and how much do humans? The answer has changed with technology, because technology is what lets a society loosen the hold of its environment. A society with very little technology lives directly off nature — it hunts, gathers and grows what the land and climate allow — and is said to be naturalised. A society with advanced technology reshapes its surroundings and leaves its imprint everywhere, and nature is said to be humanised.
| View | What it holds | How to recognise it |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental determinism | In the early stages of civilisation, with little technology, humans listened to and obeyed the dictates of nature; nature was a powerful force, worshipped and feared — "Mother Nature". | A community depending directly on the forest or the land, with nature setting the terms |
| Possibilism | As technology grows, humans understand nature better and create possibilities with its resources; nature offers opportunities and humans make use of them. | Human imprints: health resorts on highlands, urban sprawls, fields and orchards, ports on coasts, ocean routes, satellites in space |
| Neodeterminism — Griffith Taylor | A middle path: neither absolute necessity nor absolute freedom. Humans can conquer nature by obeying it — they must respond to its "red signals" and may proceed when it gives the "green". | "Stop and go determinism"; development that respects limits |
Human Geography Through the Corridors of Time
- Early colonial periodExploration and description — imperial and trade interests drove the discovery and description of new areas
- Later colonial periodRegional analysis — all aspects of a region described in detail, to understand the whole through its parts
- Inter-war period (1930s)Areal differentiation — why and how one region differs from another
- Late 1950s to late 1960sSpatial organisation — computers and sophisticated statistical tools; the quantitative revolution
- 1970sHumanistic, radical and behavioural schools emerge, in reaction to the quantitative approach
- 1990sPost-modernism — grand generalisations questioned; the local context stressed
The 1970s reaction produced three schools, and the paper asks them by their concerns. The welfare or humanistic school was concerned with the social well-being of people — housing, health, education. The radical school used Marxian theory to explain the basic causes of poverty, deprivation and social inequality, linking contemporary social problems to the development of capitalism. The behavioural school laid great emphasis on lived experience and on how space is perceived by social categories based on ethnicity, race and religion.
Fields and Sub-fields, and Their Sister Disciplines
Because it is integrative, human geography overlaps with the other social sciences, and each of its fields has grown beside a sister discipline. The main fields are social geography, urban geography, political geography, population geography, settlement geography and economic geography, each with sub-fields of its own.
| Field | Sub-field | Sister discipline |
|---|---|---|
| Social geography | Behavioural geography | Psychology |
| Social geography | Geography of social well-being | Welfare economics |
| Social geography | Cultural geography | Anthropology |
| Social geography | Historical geography | History |
| Social geography | Medical geography | Epidemiology |
| Urban geography | — | Urban studies and planning |
| Political geography | Electoral geography | Psephology (election analysis) |
| Political geography | Military geography | Military science |
| Population geography | — | Demography |
| Economic geography | Resource geography | Resource economics |
| Economic geography | Agricultural geography | Agricultural sciences |
| Economic geography | Industrial geography | Industrial economics |
| Economic geography | Geography of tourism | Tourism and travel management |
Key takeaways
- Human geography studies the inter-relationship between the physical environment and the socio-cultural environment humans create.
- Ratzel: "synthetic study" of human societies and the earth’s surface; Semple: "unresting man and the unstable earth"; Vidal de la Blache: "physical laws" and "living beings".
- Low technology means naturalised humans (environmental determinism); advanced technology means humanised nature (possibilism).
- Griffith Taylor’s neodeterminism, "stop and go determinism", is the middle path: conquer nature by obeying it.
- Approaches in order: exploration and description, regional analysis, areal differentiation, spatial organisation, the humanistic–radical–behavioural schools, post-modernism.
- Welfare school: well-being; radical school: Marxian causes of poverty and inequality; behavioural school: lived experience and perception of space.
- Each sub-field has a sister discipline: medical–epidemiology, electoral–psephology, population–demography, historical–history, military–military science.
Practice questions (8)
Attempt each one before opening the answer. Every explanation names the tempting wrong option as well as the right one, because that is where marks are lost.
Who defined human geography as "the study of the changing relationship between the unresting man and the unstable earth"?
Show answer
Answer: B — Ellen Churchill Semple
The words "unresting man" and "unstable earth" belong to Ellen Churchill Semple. Ratzel called human geography the synthetic study of human societies and the earth’s surface, Vidal de la Blache spoke of physical laws and the living beings that inhabit the earth, and Griffith Taylor is known for neodeterminism rather than a definition.A community with very little technology lives off the forest, worships nature and adjusts every activity to what its environment allows. This illustrates:
Show answer
Answer: C — Environmental determinism
When technology is low, humans obey the dictates of nature and are "naturalised" — the view called environmental determinism. Possibilism needs technology that lets humans create opportunities from nature, neodeterminism is the later middle path of obeying nature’s limits by choice, and post-modernism is an approach of the 1990s, not a stage of the human–nature relationship.The concept of "stop and go determinism", in which humans may proceed with development when nature gives the green signal, was put forward by:
Show answer
Answer: A — Griffith Taylor
Griffith Taylor proposed neodeterminism, also called stop and go determinism: humans neither obey nature absolutely nor command it freely, but heed its red signals and move ahead on the green. The other three are known for their definitions of human geography, and Vidal de la Blache in particular is associated with the possibilist tradition, which the concept was meant to temper.The use of computers and sophisticated statistical tools in human geography, often called the quantitative revolution, marks which approach and period?
Show answer
Answer: D — Spatial organisation, late 1950s to late 1960s
Spatial organisation, from the late 1950s to the late 1960s, was marked by computers and statistical tools — the quantitative revolution — used to find mappable patterns of human phenomena. Areal differentiation asked why regions differ, regional analysis described each region in detail, and exploration and description belong to the earliest colonial stage.Match List-I (sub-field of human geography) with List-II (sister discipline):
List-I: A. Electoral geography B. Medical geography C. Historical geography D. Military geography
List-II: I. Epidemiology II. Psephology III. Military science IV. HistoryShow answer
Answer: D — A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Electoral geography studies voting patterns, as psephology does; medical geography studies the spread of disease, as epidemiology does; historical geography pairs with history and military geography with military science. The tempting near-miss swaps historical and military geography, and another swaps electoral and medical geography — read each pair on its own.Which school of human geography used Marxian theory to explain the basic causes of poverty, deprivation and social inequality?
Show answer
Answer: B — The radical school
The radical school drew on Marxian theory and linked poverty, deprivation and inequality to the development of capitalism. The welfare school was concerned with well-being — housing, health and education — without that explanatory theory, the behavioural school stressed lived experience and perception of space, and spatial organisation was the quantitative approach all three reacted against.Assertion (A): In technologically advanced societies, nature is said to be humanised.
Reason (R): With technology, humans create possibilities with the resources of nature and leave their imprints, such as health resorts, ports and orchards, on the environment.Show answer
Answer: A — Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Both statements are true, and the reason is exactly why nature is called humanised: technology lets people turn natural resources into possibilities and stamp the landscape with resorts, ports, orchards and cities. This is the possibilist view. The pairing fails only if R described something unrelated to the human imprint, which it does not.Consider the following statements:
A. The behavioural school emphasised lived experience and the perception of space by social categories.
B. The welfare school was concerned with housing, health and education.
C. Areal differentiation was the dominant approach of the inter-war period.
D. Post-modernism in geography emerged in the 1950s.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:Show answer
Answer: C — A, B and C only
A, B and C are true: the behavioural school stressed lived experience, the welfare school social well-being, and areal differentiation dominated the inter-war years. D is false — post-modernism belongs to the 1990s; the late 1950s and 1960s were the years of spatial organisation and the quantitative revolution. Leaving out C, or keeping D, gives one of the wrong combinations.